Handling invoices from businesses that have absconded: How to explain, adjust, and prevent risks.

Processing invoices when the seller has abandoned their address; Bizzi logo

When discovering that an invoice from a supplier is no longer issued at their registered address, the accountant needs to verify the tax authority's identification date, compare the invoice date, and review the transaction records before deciding on an explanation or adjustment. The current status of the seller is not sufficient to draw the same conclusion for all issued invoices.

Things to do first: Create a list of relevant invoices, record verification information, and categorize items that have been declared for VAT, included in corporate income tax expenses, and included in tax refund applications. Clearly indicate existing documents, missing documents, and content for which the competent authority has reached a conclusion.

Five steps to take when you discover a related invoice.

  1. Gather verification information. Record the notification, conclusion, or search result along with the source and date. The output is a record clearly identifying the information already available and the content requiring further inquiry.
  2. Compare each invoice with the relevant date. Record the date of creation, the date the tax authority determined, and the scope of the conclusion. The output is a categorized list, not a general conclusion for all of the seller's invoices.
  3. Joining transaction documents. This includes contracts, purchase orders (POs), deliveries, payments, and accounting entries. The output is a table of matching documents, discrepancies, and missing records.
  4. Determine your tax status. Separate the undeclared, deducted, and expense-deductible corporate income tax amounts, as well as those related to tax refunds. The output should be the period and the data to be reviewed for each type of document.
  5. Develop a plan for handling the situation and assign responsibility to those in charge. Prepare explanations, make adjustments when necessary, and monitor for additional requests. Keep records of the decision, the person responsible, and the results; do not alter documents to conceal discrepancies.

If the seller abandons their address, does that render all issued invoices illegal?

It's impossible to conclude the entirety of an invoice solely from the label "absconded." It's necessary to distinguish the seller's status from the legality of each invoice, the date of issue, and the relevant verification findings. "Absconded" is a common term; when processing the case, accurately record the status and content of the tax authority's notification.

Businesses that have ceased operations, are not operating at their registered address, or have a risk warning are situations that require specific verification. These terms should not be used interchangeably, nor should they be interpreted as implying that the buyer has engaged in invoice trading.

Verified information Points to identify Review direction
Invoices issued from the date the tax authorities determine that the seller is not operating at the registered address. This falls under the category of using illegal invoices as stated in Clause 7, Article 3 of Decree 254. Compare specific documents, invoices, declaration periods, and processing responsibilities; do not rely solely on documents proving receipt of goods.
Invoices issued before the aforementioned date. It is not automatically safe. It is necessary to check for illegal conclusions from competent authorities and other illegal grounds. Review the actual records and corresponding tax conditions; clearly separate known facts from information awaiting verification.
Only the current alert or search status is available. Information regarding the milestones and conclusions related to each invoice has not yet been replaced. Record the source and date of the lookup; verify the document and scope instead of automatically assigning conclusions to all invoices.

The date the accounting department discovers the risk is not a substitute for the date determined by the tax authority. Similarly, an invoice lookup result existing in the system does not automatically prove that goods were delivered, services were completed, or all deduction conditions were met.

Illustrating the three steps of verifying tax milestones, comparing invoices, and reviewing records.
This illustrates the review process. The results of each step serve as input for processing the application and do not replace the conclusions of the competent authority.

What checks are needed before filing a tax return or making a tax adjustment?

Create a general tracking table for each invoice. This table should link invoice information, transaction details, payment information, and reporting period; and mark any unverified data.

  • Invoice number, symbol, and date; name and tax identification number of the seller; value of goods and services, and VAT.
  • Date of delivery, acceptance, or completion of service; date of actual payment.
  • Date the tax authorities determined the seller was not operating at the registered address; number, date, and scope of relevant documents, if any.
  • Conclusions from the tax authorities, police, or other competent authority regarding the specific invoice, if available.
  • The XML file, PDF representation, and search results are saved with the date and source of the check.
  • A contract, purchase order, or document indicating a need to purchase goods or services.
  • Receipts, acceptance and handover records; warehouse entry and exit slips, bills of lading, or service performance documents.
  • Payment documents and payment document conditions must be applicable to the correct transaction and the correct period.
  • The purpose of using inputs in business operations and the related accounting documentation.
  • Status of VAT declaration, corporate income tax settlement, tax refunds, and inspections/audits.

When checking the supplier status, you can refer to the following: How to look up tax code. Save the results at a specific point in time instead of just capturing a screenshot of the final state.

When you need to check multiple input invoices, see the procedure. Bulk electronic invoice lookup. The lookup results must be linked to the transaction record and not used independently to determine deductions.

If the invoice appears in Source of the list of risky businesses, It is necessary to read the text, scope, and period mentioned correctly. The summary list is not a substitute for verifying each invoice individually.

When the application is incomplete: Record the missing documents accurately, the person responsible for searching, and the response deadline. You may request the supplier, bank, or user department to provide the actual documents that were generated. Do not create false records, backdate documents, or request invoices from parties not involved in the transaction as a substitute.

What should be done when an invoice has not been declared, has already been deducted, or has already received a tax refund?

The declaration status determines which part of the work needs to be reviewed, but it doesn't solely determine the legality of the invoice. First, clarify the verification results above, then compare each tax type and the relevant period.

Situation What to do Content to be concluded
VAT deductions have not yet been declared. Mark this as pending review and verification of invoices and transaction records before filing. Does the invoice meet the deduction conditions applicable to the transaction and the period in which it was issued?
VAT has been declared and deducted. Determine the period and amount of tax declared; compile documents and process supplementary declarations when adjustments are necessary. Data on impact, basis, and procedures for adjustment in accordance with the tax audit situation.
Included as an expense when calculating corporate income tax. Compare actual expenses, business purposes, invoices, payments, and settlement documents. Conditions for deductible expenses; separate from accounting recognition and VAT deduction.
Currently applying for or already receiving a tax refund. Identify the relevant tax amount in the refund application, its processing status, and the tax authority's requirements. Additional obligations, adjustments, or processing of refunded amounts based on verification results.
There is documentation showing that the transaction was fictitious or that a violation has been concluded. Preserve the records, report to the person in charge, and cooperate in handling the matter as required by law. Specific conduct, tax obligations, and responsibilities; no alteration of records to conceal discrepancies.

Not yet declared: clarify the documentation before including it in the deduction.

Include the invoice in the list requiring verification and check the applicable conditions before filing. Not filing helps determine the scope of processing without having to reconcile the deduction recorded in the previous period; this does not mean the invoice will be accepted after any additional documentation is submitted.

If there is no clear document from the tax authorities specifying the exact date, this should be noted as missing information. The reviewer must indicate the source of the verification and the specific clarification requested, and should not make assumptions about the date the seller ceased operations.

Declarations have been filed: reconciliation for each period and adjustment based on the declaration.

Gather a list of invoices, deducted VAT amounts, related tax returns, and supporting documents. If supplementary or amended declarations are required, determine the basis, data, and procedures based on the actual tax record status, especially if an audit or inspection decision has been made.

Do not automatically reduce all invoices simply because the seller has changed their payment status; nor should you maintain the deduction just because payment has been made or goods received. Each course of action must be based on legal conditions and verification results.

Corporate income tax has been settled or the necessary documents are available: expand the scope of verification.

For expenses included in the final settlement, it is necessary to determine the tax year, the value of the expense, the documentation supporting the business operation, and the corresponding supporting documents. Accounting entries, deductible expenses for corporate income tax, and deductible VAT are three separate matters; conclusions from one matter do not automatically supersede the other two.

For tax refunds, clearly state whether the application is pending or has been processed, the related tax amount, and the relevant tax authority document. Avoid combining tax refund applications with invoices that have never been declared and applying the same processing method.

What documents can be used to verify transactions when providing explanations?

A good set of documents should connect the sales agreement, the execution, and the payment. The explanatory letter is the part that presents those facts; the letter itself does not replace the documents and does not guarantee the deduction result.

Document group Comparison content Points to clarify when something is missing or inaccurate.
Sales contracts, service contracts Subject, object, delivery and payment terms Appendix, amendment, or factual agreement based on evidence.
Purchase Order (PO), Proposal for Purchase Requirements, quantity, unit price, approver Difference between the invoice and the received goods.
Delivery, acceptance, and handover of services. Timing, quantity, and recipient Who confirmed it? The content is incomplete. Based on the handover.
Warehouse release form, warehouse receipt form, bill of lading Goods flow and receiving locations Verify warehouse, shipping unit, and direct shipment details if applicable.
Payment vouchers, bank statements Payer, recipient, amount, time Payment terms, outstanding balances, offsetting, or third parties if applicable.
XML and PDF electronic invoices Invoice data, search results, seller information Differences between versions, states, and data sources.
Accounting books, accounting documents Recording method, period, and item Differences with accounts payable, taxes, and settlement records.
Sales documents, input usage records Relationship with business operations Where was the input used, and which unit is responsible for managing it?
Emails, meeting minutes, exchanged documents The actual developments and the content confirmed by the parties. Maintain the source of the documents; distinguish between current confirmations and documents created at the time of the transaction.

Read the file in three streams: transaction agreement, goods or services performed and payment. For example, discrepancies between the quantity on the purchase order and the quantity on the warehouse receipt require explanation and supporting documentation; bank statements only prove the flow of money, they do not automatically prove the entire content of the invoice.

Illustrating the documents that need to be organized for transaction reconciliation.
The image is for illustrative purposes only and does not constitute a conclusion regarding the legality of a specific invoice.

What information should a letter of explanation include?

The content can be organized into the six groups below and adjusted according to the actual requirements of the tax authorities. This is a reference framework, not a mandatory template for all documents, and no downloadable file is included.

Content section Information to be presented
1. The company provides an explanation. Name, tax identification number, address, representative, contact person; number and date of the request document, if any.
2. Related invoices Number, symbol, date of issue, value of goods and services, VAT, and declared period.
3. Supplier and verification results Name, tax identification number, address; transaction date; identification point and content of the document from the competent authority.
4. Transaction developments The need to purchase, negotiate, deliver or inspect, pay for, and use of inputs.
5. Document List Number contracts, purchase orders, delivery notes, warehouse records, payment documents, XML/PDF files, accounting records, and related documents; specify the page number or reference file code.
6. Proposal content and responsibilities State the issues requiring clarification, any missing documents, and the processing status; confirm the accuracy of information for which the business is responsible.

If a fact is undetermined, the situation and the steps taken to find it must be presented accurately. Do not turn speculation into confirmation. Subsequent supplementary documentation must correctly state the source and date, avoiding backdating to give the impression that the file was complete from the beginning.

If all transaction documents are available, is it possible to deduct VAT and include it as a corporate income tax expense?

It's impossible to draw conclusions simply from having sufficient documentation. The legality of the invoice and the applicable tax conditions need to be assessed; a single actual transaction doesn't make every invoice legitimate.

  • VAT: Verify the invoice, the purpose of the input, the payment documents, and the deduction conditions applicable to the transaction and the period in which it occurred.
  • Corporate Income Tax: Verify the actual expenditure, its relationship to business operations, supporting invoices and receipts, payment procedures, and the corresponding conditions for deductible expenses.
  • Accountant: Reflect business operations according to their nature and applicable regulations; separately track the handling of discrepancies when determining tax obligations.

Hypothetical example: The invoice was issued before the tax authorities determined that the seller was no longer operating at the registered address, and the business has a delivery receipt and money transfer documents. The accountant must still verify the invoice's conclusions, tax conditions, and the purpose of the input materials. These two documents do not guarantee automatic deduction. If the service acceptance is not yet found, record the gap requiring clarification; do not create a report with an outdated date.

Which approaches make it easier to explain away a case that's difficult to justify?

  1. Eliminate or keep all invoices based on their current status. Please categorize by invoice, reference point, conclusion, and declaration status.
  2. Save only as PDF. Keep the XML and proof-of-reference data for comparison; don't consider the instance as the entire record.
  3. Just process the documents, skip the delivery and receipt process. The official document must include supporting evidence.
  4. Payment terms were not checked. Assessment is based on the transaction and the applicable period; not every transferred amount is considered to fully meet tax requirements.
  5. Combine the shutdown status with the conclusion of a violation. Read the information carefully, understanding the source, context, and scope of the announcement.
  6. Do not separate files that have been filed, refunded, or are under audit. Each situation requires different procedures and data verification.
  7. Create or modify documents to legitimize the transaction. Use only authentic material; refrain from adding supplementary information and misinterpreting it.
  8. No one has been assigned to handle this. Each file requires a designated person, supporting documents, and a clear processing deadline.

Where do you start establishing a process for controlling incoming invoices?

Start by identifying verifiable points in the purchasing and payment process, then record the results for each invoice. The goal is to detect information requiring verification early and retrieve records when a request arises.

  1. Verify the supplier before making a transaction. Save the tax identification number, search status, source, inspection date, and person performing the search; update when changes occur.
  2. Check the invoice upon receipt. Compare the seller, content, XML data, and search results. Note down any discrepancies that need clarification.
  3. Compare the transaction documents. Connect invoices to contracts, purchase orders, deliveries, or acceptance reports; do not overlook discrepancies in quantity, unit price, and timing.
  4. Centralized record keeping. Keep XML, PDF, payment, and delivery documents organized by file code so that the person in charge can easily retrieve them.
  5. Review the processing milestones beforehand. Check for missing documents before filing, paying, settling, or requesting tax refunds; the decision on how to handle the matter rests with the responsible person.
  6. Follow up until the file is closed. The list should include invoices awaiting verification, missing documents, received notifications, and processing results; not just a warning label.

How does Bizzi assist in the process of cross-referencing and compiling documents?

Bizzi's solution for processing input invoices. It supports data organization and reconciliation of invoices with purchase orders and delivery receipts according to the deployment configuration. This reconciliation helps accountants identify discrepancies for further verification; it does not replace legal verification and tax compliance.

The image illustrates Bizzi's solution for comparing invoices with purchase orders and delivery documents.
This is an illustration of Bizzi's three-dimensional reconciliation. Interface and functionality depend on the deployment configuration; the reconciliation results are not conclusive evidence of tax eligibility.

When evaluating implementation, use a set of records with factual discrepancies to test the ability to link documents, the way tasks are assigned to responsible persons, and the accessibility of information. Accountants still need to verify unclear content, decide on the course of action, and take responsibility for the declared records.

Frequently Asked Questions When Handling Invoices Where the Seller Has Removed Their Address

Are invoices issued before the seller's address is determined to be abandoned safe?

There is no automatic guarantee. It is necessary to verify the conclusion of the competent authority regarding the invoice, other illegal grounds, and related tax conditions. The benchmark for verification is the date the tax authority determines the information, not the date the buyer first learns of the information.

If the VAT has already been declared, do I need to make an adjustment immediately?

It is necessary to identify the invoice, reporting period, verification results, and basis for adjustment. Do not make adjustments indiscriminately based solely on risk labels; if there is a basis for adjustment, follow the corresponding procedures, and retain the data and explanatory documents.

Does having expenses already accounted for mean they are deductible from corporate income tax?

No. Accounting recognition and determining deductible expenses are two separate matters that require separate evaluation. The expense must meet applicable tax conditions, not just be based on accounting entries or money transfer documents.

Is it necessary to send a formal explanation in all cases?

Review the requirements and obligations applicable to the specific file. When clarification is needed, the letter should support clear documentation and figures; preparing a letter does not replace reviewing the declaration or performing necessary adjustment procedures.

If a handover record is missing, can it be created to complete the process?

It is necessary to find actual documents, truthfully verify the events that occurred, and record the correct date of creation of the supplementary documents. Do not create transactions, backdate them, or use documents from another party to replace fictitious transactions.

Does the software determine whether the invoice is eligible for tax deduction?

The software can assist in organizing and cross-referencing data within the scope of its implemented functions. Data verification results or alerts do not replace legal conclusions, tax conditions, or the business's responsibilities.

Trở lại