In recent years, along with the tax authorities' efforts to strengthen the management of electronic invoices and the application of risk analysis systems, behavioral patterns have become more prevalent. purchase and sale invoices This is becoming one of the most serious legal and tax risks for businesses. Businesses need to check invoices and actual transaction records. Any irregularities must be verified; administrative or criminal liability must be based on the conduct, fault, and conditions stipulated by law.
So What is invoice trading?Why is this behavior dealt with so severely, and what can businesses do to prevent it?
What is invoice trading?
Buying and selling invoices is an act Buying, selling, leasing, and transferring the right to use invoices. but not related to actual transactions involving the purchase or sale of goods or the provision of services..
In other words, the invoice was created. just to legitimize the documents, which does not reflect actual economic transactions.
Key points the tax authorities consider:
- Bill does not reflect the nature of economic transactions..
- Not fully available Product flow – service flow – cash flow.
It is necessary to distinguish clearly:
- Issue a legitimate invoice.: There is a real transaction, a contract, delivery, acceptance, and payment.
- Buying and selling invoices: only the invoice, but There are no corresponding economic transactions..
Types of invoices that are commonly bought and sold.
In reality, the buying and selling of invoices does not take place in a single form. Tax authorities usually classify them according to... the nature of the use and purpose of the fraud.
Common types include:
- Buying and selling VAT invoices (red invoice) to increase costs or deduct VAT.
- Invoice rental According to the % ratio, the value is used to legitimize the expenses.
- Fake invoices, counterfeit invoices Issued by a "phantom" company.
- Electronic bill There is information that needs verification., For example, the search data may not match. The inability to retrieve the data could be due to incorrect information, search scope, or system errors; this result alone is not sufficient to conclude that the invoice is fake.
During the inspection, it is sufficient to... a weak link In the invoice chain, all transactions are subject to risk assessment.

What is the legal nature of buying and selling invoices?
It is necessary to distinguish between the illegal buying and selling of invoices and errors in the preparation or receipt of invoices. The actions and responsibilities of each party must be determined from the transaction, records, errors, and corresponding processing conditions; not every error constitutes tax evasion or a crime.
Regarding electronic invoices, verification will be required from July 1, 2026. Decree 254/2026/ND-CP. Regarding administrative penalties, please refer to Decree 125/2020/ND-CP and its amending documents, including: Decree 291/2026/ND-CP, effective July 21, 2026. In cases where there are indications of a crime, this must be determined separately according to the Criminal Code.
Why does the buying and selling of invoices occur?
The buying and selling of invoices didn't happen by chance. There are underlying reasons behind it. Financial, tax, and management motivations very specific.
1. Evading Corporate Income Tax (CIT)
This is the most common cause in the cases that have been discovered.
Businesses purchase invoices for the following reasons:
- Increase deductible expenses
- Reduce taxable profit
- "Filling in" expenses for undocumented expenditures.
Many businesses consider this a short-term solution, but when it comes to final accounting, the risks become apparent. All costs were excluded. It is very large.
2. Value Added Tax (VAT) Fraud
Some businesses purchase input invoices for the following purposes:
- Increase in deductible VAT
- Incorrect tax refund
In the current management system, VAT data needs to be compared with transactions and declaration records. Because data can be quickly cross-referenced across multiple systems.
3. Legitimizing expenses and assets "off the books"
Invoices are used for:
- Legalizing expenses outside of a planned budget.
- Concealing vested interests
- Creating a “legal shell” for illicit money flows.
This is a group of risks that often lead to expanded investigation.
4. Improve your financial profile.
Some businesses use invoices for:
- Creating fictitious revenue
- Increase the reporting scale.
- Serving loan and bidding purposes.
The risk is that if discovered, the business Serious damage to reputation with banks and partners..
5. Weak internal controls
Many businesses are facing risks. not due to intentional fraud, which is due to:
- There is no invoice approval process.
- No reconciliation of Purchase Order – Gross Price – Invoice
- Manual processing, lack of warning tools.
These are the businesses that are most likely to "accidentally fall into a trap".
Distinguish between risk indicators and conclusions of violations.
Invoices and records must reflect actual transactions, be properly accounted for, and comply with applicable regulations. The fact that a supplier is temporarily suspended or not operating at their registered address is information that needs to be verified at the time of invoice and transaction record creation, and is not the sole basis for classifying all their invoices as illegal sales invoices.
When discrepancies are found, businesses should record the investigation results, request explanations from the supplier, and compare them with the contract, delivery, or acceptance and payment procedures. If requested by a competent authority, they must prepare the necessary documents in accordance with the request.
Typical violations related to the buying and selling of invoices.
In practice, during tax audits and inspections, the tax authorities... Don't just look at a single invoice., which evaluate The use of invoices throughout the entire transaction chain.Below are some of the most typical violations that are often detected and dealt with.
Using fictitious invoices or invoices for purchases made outside the company.
This is the most common behavior and also a "red flag" in the tax risk management system.
Common symptoms:
- There were no economic contracts or contracts signed that were merely ceremonial.
- There are no delivery receipts or service acceptance reports.
- No actual payments or round-trip payments, or payments made on behalf of others, occurred.
In essence, a business only buy invoices, without purchasing corresponding goods or services. When the cash flow, goods flow, and invoice flow do not match, the business needs to verify the cause and supplement the documentation before deciding on a course of action.
Legalizing expenses and claiming tax refunds.
Many businesses use external invoices to "cover expenses" for expenditures that lack valid supporting documents.
Common behaviors:
- Recording fictitious expenses to reduce corporate income tax payable.
- Creating fictitious goods and services to increase input VAT for tax deduction or refund purposes.
- Extending the invoice chain through multiple intermediary companies to conceal the source of the invoices.
This is a group of behaviors. were severely punished.This not only leads to revenue losses but also distorts tax data.
Using invoices to obtain loans and manipulate financial statements.
Some businesses don't buy invoices to evade taxes, but rather to "beautify" their financial records.
The purpose is usually:
- Creating fictitious revenue to increase bank credit limits.
- Scale up your business when participating in bidding and fundraising.
- Concealing the actual state of poor business performance.
The risk lies in the fact that when tax authorities or banks conduct cross-checking, the business may... Loss of both credibility and access to capital..
A chain of "ghost" businesses specializing in selling invoices.
This is a form of organized violation, often closely monitored by tax authorities and economic police.
Characteristic:
- Establishing a business solely for the purpose of issuing VAT invoices.
- There is no actual business activity.
- Collecting money for providing invoices that are not related to actual goods or services.
- After a short time, they abscond, dissolve, or cease operations.
Businesses purchase invoices from these "phantom businesses". It is very difficult to defend the costs., even if there is a "legitimate" contract or document.
Information that suppliers need to verify.
When choosing a supplier, it's necessary to check their registration information, operational status, and transaction capabilities. Small, newly established businesses with few employees or no website cannot prove they are legitimate businesses involved in buying and selling invoices.
- Compare the tax identification number, name, address, and seller information on the contract and invoice.
- Verify the documentation proving the delivery or provision of services: delivery receipts, acceptance certificates, and matching output documents.
- Clarify discrepancies regarding quantity, unit price, recipient of payment, or payment documents.
- When receiving risk warnings from the tax authorities, carefully read the scope, timing, and verification requirements; do not jump to conclusions about criminal activity.
Identifying fake invoices, fictitious invoices, and risky invoices.
Early identification is the most effective way to avoid risk. In fact, the bill of risk. They often reveal signs in multiple layers., and it's not just on the surface of the invoice.
Indicators on invoices and systems
This is the first and easiest test to perform.
Warning signs:
- Unable to retrieve invoices on the electronic invoice portal.
- Incorrect tax identification number, incorrect seller name, or incorrect seller address.
- The invoice date does not match the actual transaction date.
If even one of these elements doesn't match, the invoice is already under suspicion.
Signs regarding accompanying documents
The invoice is just the "final result," but the tax authorities are always looking at the rest. backend documentation.
Risk factors:
- There was no economic contract or agreement signed after the invoice.
- There are no purchase orders, acceptance reports, or warehouse receipts.
- Large cash payments were made without any bank transfer documentation.
Incomplete documentation causes businesses to... It is difficult to explain the nature and basis of the expenditure..
Indicators of the business issuing the invoice.
Even if the invoice looks "good," the issuing company is still the deciding factor.
Special attention is needed when:
- Newly established business, small capital, but constantly issuing invoices.
- The business is temporarily suspended, has ceased operations, or has abandoned its address.
- There is no website, and no clear operational information.
Quick check before accounting
Perform check valid electronic invoice along with the transaction records. For descriptions of goods, services, and reference documents, see How to record invoice content according to the contract..
To reduce risk, accountants and finance departments should develop a habit of performing quick checks using checklists:
- Look up your invoice on the electronic invoice portal.
- Look up the tax identification number and business operating status.
- Compare the contents of the invoice with:
- Contract
- Purchase Order (PO)
- Handover/Acceptance Record (GR)
- Payment documents
If a mismatched linkTherefore, invoices should be placed under risk monitoring instead of being accounted for immediately.
Tax risks and consequences of using unauthorized sales invoices.
Using unauthorized sales invoices is not just an accounting error or a short-term tax trick. In fact, it is an act classified by the tax authorities as a crime. high risk groupThis can lead to a range of serious tax, financial, and legal consequences for businesses.
Risks related to VAT and corporate income tax.
The obligation to adjust taxes should be determined based on the conclusions, records, and regulations applicable to each specific case.
Specifically:
- Input VAT is not deductible.
All VAT declared and deducted from illegal sales invoices will be disallowed. Businesses are required to:- Supplementary declaration/adjustment.
- Repay the incorrectly deducted tax amount.
- Expenses that are excluded from deductible expenses when calculating corporate income tax.
Expenses arising from external purchase invoices will not be considered valid expenses. This results in:- Increase taxable profits.
- Increase the amount of corporate income tax payable, even if the expenses have actually been incurred.
- Tax collection and calculation of late payment penalties.
In addition to the back taxes, businesses also have to pay late payment penalties calculated based on the number of days of violation, significantly increasing the total financial loss.
Administrative penalties: identifying the correct act and timing.
A single penalty should not be applied to all cases involving incorrect invoices or suspected invoice trading. The specific actions, timing, parties involved, tax consequences, and transitional provisions must be identified. When consulting Decree 125/2020/ND-CP, current amendments, including Decree 291/2026/ND-CP, should be considered; the old penalty schedule alone should not be used to determine how to handle such cases.
Distinguishing between Article 200 and Article 203 of the Penal Code
The use of illegal invoices may be related to tax evasion under Article 200 if all the elements of the crime are present. The illegal printing, issuance, and sale of invoices may be prosecuted under Article 203 if the conditions of the law are met. It is impossible to conclude guilt based solely on an invoice error or an unusual search result.
According to The guidance from the General Department of Taxation was published on the Government Portal on June 14, 2024., Article 203 outlines two main penalty frameworks for individuals, with prison sentences ranging from 6 months to 5 years; the law also stipulates fines or non-custodial rehabilitation depending on the case. Commercial legal entities have separate sanctions. When handling specific cases, it is necessary to compare the law and its amending documents in effect at the time of application, rather than considering this summary as a conclusion for the business.
Financial, operational, and reputational impacts on the business.
Beyond tax and legal issues, the indirect consequences of using unauthorized sales invoices are often long-lasting and difficult to remedy.
Common impacts include:
- Cash flow is tied up.
When an invoice is rejected or pending verification, the business can:- Unable to issue invoices to customers.
- Payment was not collected on time.
→ Cash flow is disrupted, which is especially dangerous for businesses that rely on short-term cash flow.
- Listed as a high-risk business.
When verification or inspection is required, businesses need to prepare to:- Provide the documents as requested.
- Monitor the corrective actions taken and keep a record of the explanatory documents for future verification.
- Loss of trust from partners and banks.
Businesses that face invoice-related risks often experience:- The partner requested stricter payment terms.
- Banks tighten credit, reduce credit limits, or require additional collateral.
The process by which tax authorities inspect and detect the buying and selling of invoices.
Many businesses believe that simply "manipulating" documents is enough to deceive tax authorities. In reality, current control processes rely heavily on... big data analysis and cross-referencing, no longer dependent on single manual checks.
Data analysis on e-Invoice, eTax, and TMS systems.
The tax authorities use centralized data to:
- Match Revenue – Input – Inventory – Taxes Payable.
- Detect the unusual fluctuations like:
- Revenue fluctuates dramatically, sometimes increasing and sometimes decreasing.
- The invoice value does not reflect the company's capabilities.
- An unusually high frequency of invoice issuance in a short period of time.
The system can automatically place businesses under surveillance without requiring immediate on-site inspections.
Cross-reference with banks and other data sources.
In many cases, tax data is compared with:
- Banking transactions.
- Anti-money laundering data.
- Customs data, business registration.
Unusual payment transactions (round transfers, unclear details, large but disproportionately large amounts) will be considered. deep inspection trigger point.
Send notifications and requests for explanations from businesses.
When there are signs of risk, the tax authorities will:
- Send a notification or official letter requesting an explanation.
- The following information is required from the business:
- Economic contract.
- Delivery and acceptance documents.
- Payment voucher.
- Detailed inventory list (purchases, sales, and stock levels).
The explanatory documents must be consistent with the actual transaction. If the documentation is insufficient, the business should clarify the missing parts as required, rather than speculating about the outcome of the processing.
Draw conclusions and apply corrective measures.
After compiling and evaluating the documents, the tax authorities will:
- Draw a conclusion regarding the legality of the invoice.
- Implement the following measures:
- Tax collection.
- Administrative penalties.
- In cases where there are signs of criminal activity: Transfer the case file to the investigating agency..
More importantly, this result will be Recorded in the risk management systemThis will affect the evaluation of the business in subsequent periods.
Verify the documents with Bizzi after the transaction has been confirmed.
When dealing with a large number of invoices, businesses need to consolidate data and assign personnel to process discrepancies before accounting or payment. Bizzi's solution for processing input invoices and matching documents. Support in verifying invoice data, supplier information, and comparing invoices with purchase orders and warehouse receipts within the scope of implementation.
The audit results are for accounting and authorized review purposes only, not a conclusion on whether the transaction is genuine or whether it is eligible for tax deduction. Businesses still need records of delivery, acceptance, payment, and handling of exceptions.
Differentiate the tasks at each step.
- Input invoices: data collection, document reconciliation, and verification of discrepancies.
- Output invoices: created with accurate information and timing according to actual transactions; the software does not automatically determine the legal nature of the invoice on behalf of the person creating it.
- Expenses: Link expenses to supporting documents and approval history for auditing purposes.
- Accounts receivable: tracking accounts receivable and collection progress, separate from determining the legality of invoices.
The image illustrates Bizzi's suite of invoicing, expense management, and accounts receivable solutions; the interface and features depend on the deployment configuration.



If a process needs to be implemented, businesses should identify the data source, exception handler, and approval authority before selecting the appropriate configuration.
Frequently Asked Questions about Invoice Trading
What is invoice trading, and how is it different from fraudulent invoices?
A fictitious invoice is a form of invoice trading.
Can invoices that are not associated with actual transactions be used as a basis for expense deductions?
Invoices that do not reflect actual transactions cannot be used to legitimize expenses. Adjustments to tax obligations and penalties depend on the documentation, conduct, and applicable regulations.
Can I go to jail if I'm caught buying fake invoices?
Yes, if all the elements constituting the crime under Article 203 of the Penal Code are present.
Is there any software that can help avoid the risks associated with fraudulent invoice trading?
The tool can assist in data collection, document reconciliation, and discrepancy alerts. Transaction verification and processing decisions remain the responsibility of the business and the competent authority.
Conclude
What is invoice trading? This is no longer a theoretical question, but has become a real risk for many businesses as tax authorities intensify control over electronic invoices and data-driven risk management. The essence of invoice trading lies not in the invoice itself, but in the process of... Invoices not associated with actual economic transactionsThis leads to a range of consequences related to taxation, legal matters, finance, and corporate reputation.
In reality, quite a few businesses unintentional violationHowever, they are still drawn into the risk of invoice trading due to weak internal controls, lax invoicing-expense-accounts receivable processes, or excessive reliance on manual processing. In such cases, the consequences extend beyond disallowed expenses or tax arrears; they can lead to severe penalties, operational disruptions, and loss of trust from partners.
Therefore, instead of only addressing the issue after it has occurred, businesses need to... Proactively prevent the risks of invoice trading right from the source.By standardizing the process of receiving, checking, and reconciling invoices, ensuring transparency in expenses, and building a clear and consistent financial data platform, this is the most sustainable way to protect businesses from increasingly complex tax risks in the current period.
Sign up here to try Bizzi products: https://bizzi.vn/dang-ky-dung-thu/